Why I still save a permanent note when it has nothing to link to

You’ve just written a permanent note, you go looking for something to link it to, and there’s nothing. Do you bin it, force a weak link, or save it anyway? I would save it, and in this post I’ll explain why.

In my Beginners guide to permanent notes post, I said: “Ideally, every permanent note you create would link to another related idea within a permanent note. However, this isn’t always possible, and that’s perfectly fine.”

Yet there are other Zettelkasten users who would disagree with me and argue that you should always add a link, whatever the situation.

A board of linked notes with one orphaned note. Yet part of the same slipbox.

The case for linking

A permanent note is atomic: it explains a single idea and should make sense on its own. But it’s the links between these atomic notes that give a Zettelkasten its structure.

Each link you create between notes improves the chance of you retrieving a note in the future. Links act as pathways through your ideas.

And finally, linking our notes mirrors how we learn. Our minds are always looking to connect new ideas with existing ones: A is like B, C is the opposite of B. So linking our notes should help us to learn.

These are all sound reasons, and they’re why, if you can link one permanent note to another, you should always do so.

Why I save the note without a link anyway

A note can come before its links. This is especially true when you first start keeping a Zettelkasten, or when you start exploring a new field of knowledge. As I put it in my Beginners guide to permanent notes: “at any point in the future, you might link a new permanent note to that previously orphaned note. This brings that original idea to the forefront, potentially sparking another idea.” If I didn’t save a note just because it had no link, I’d lose any chance of this happening.

I suppose I could put a weak link to another note, but I think that could lead to a misunderstanding of what is related and what isn’t related.

Niklas Luhmann was well known for his Zettelkasten, which consisted of physical cards kept in a slip-box. When he created a new permanent note, he would file it after the first relevant note he came across, the physical equivalent of creating a link. If he couldn’t find one, he placed it at the back of his slip-box.

There is one key difference between Luhmann’s physical system and my digital notes. Luhmann’s unlinked note still had a physical place at the back of his slip-box, whereas the digital file containing my note could be anywhere in my slip-box folder. But what happens the next time Luhmann can’t find a related note? It goes to the back of the slip-box, and the previous one is no longer at the end.

Because it was a physical system, Luhmann gave every note he created a reference, and every related note built on that reference. Digital systems don’t do this by default, and mine doesn’t, though Obsidian’s Unique note creator core plugin will give each new note a unique timestamp reference.

I suppose my alternative is the index I keep of every permanent note, which, when you think about it, means none of my notes are orphaned as such. But they are still separated from other ideas in my vault, so I would still consider them orphaned.

The fact is that my Zettelkasten, like Luhmann’s or your own, will never be finished. The notes in it are never finished either. As I synthesise new content, it could add new permanent notes or lead to changes to existing ones.

My Zettelkasten is a travelling companion through life. It reflects my intellectual development over the five years since I started it.

What my numbers say

I currently have 87 orphaned notes in my Zettelkasten of 2,094 permanent notes, which means about 4% of my Zettelkasten is orphaned.

At the time of my quarterly review, I had 93, but the review generated by Claude suggested links for 6 of those notes. I took a look at them and was able to add links.

It also means that I haven’t added any further orphaned notes to my vault, which indicates that I link my notes whenever I can.

My recent numbers suggest that there is a way back in for my orphaned notes, on the now rare occasions when I create them.

How do you manage your orphaned notes?

To be kept up to date with our most recent content, join our monthly newsletter.

Further reading

  • Beginners guide to permanent notes: My guide for beginners on creating permanent notes within a Zettelkasten
  • David B. Clear, Zettelkasten: A book on using the Zettelkasten method
  • Sönke Ahrens, How to Take Smart Notes: The book that helped me to get started on my own Zettelkasten journey
  • Quarter 4 vault review: My most recent review of my Obsidian vault and Zettelkasten

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *